You don’t need a wedding to have a wishlist. I keep everyday wishes and private gift ideas together, with free shared lists and anonymous reservations. Birthdays, Christmas, or just “I saw this and thought of you”.
This is my take on choosing a wishlist app. I’ve checked competitor details against their own sites. “Not stated” means I couldn’t verify it there.
| What matters | Bestboy | MyRegistry |
|---|---|---|
| Owner sees who reserved | Never | Not stated on the pages we read |
| AI assistants | Connect your own MCP-compatible assistant. 31 tools | Not stated on the pages we read |
| Add from any store | Paste a link or use my free Chrome extension | Any store, Chrome and Firefox extensions, barcode scanner |
| Cost | Free. Plus is invite only | No charge for a registry. Cash Gift Fund has fees |
| Gift exchange | Free, up to 30, no accounts | Up to 300. Everyone makes a gift list |
| Best known for | Shared lists, AI | Weddings, baby registries |
| Cash funds | No | Yes. PayPal, funds held five business days |
MyRegistry may suit you if you need a barcode scanner, cash funds or a gift exchange for up to 300. I keep things simple: free shared wishlists, anonymous reservations and private ideas for the people you care about. My draw fits up to 30.
MyRegistry says there’s no charge for a registry. The Cash Gift Fund has fees, including 2.5% per PayPal contribution.
No. Donation wishes can show payment details, but there’s no cash fund.
You can make a shared list and let guests reserve anonymously. It’s lighter than a full registry. Our wedding registry guide covers what to include.